The Federal Court ordered that RSJ IT Solutions cease to sell the chip through its site and any other sites it owns, they also must pay Nintendo $520,000 in damages. And to top it all off, they have to give up the names of their suppliers.

The DS has sold 125 million units. The worldwide attach rate (how many games are sold per system) is about 3.5. So 437.5 million game carts sold. Average of $30 each equals $13,125,000,000 in sales over the DS’s lifetime. That means the $520,000 in damages done to Nintendo since 2007 (when R4DS carts got popular) is ~ 0.004% of the total amount of DS game sales. Are they seriously trying to tell me that this was a threat to their business.

I think this is getting out of hand. Gadgetgear only stocked the chips, they did not pre-load them with pirated materials. They did not encourage piracy. The R4DS cart can be used for many legal purposes. I’ve said before only those caught using their R4 for illegal purposes should be considered criminal. The only way an importer/seller of the devices should be considered a criminal is if they advertise the devices as a way to play games illegally. Gadgetgear did neither of these. The mere potential to do something illegal is not a good argument. If that was so then cars would be illegal as you can use them to make an escape from a crime scene. All knives would be illegal as you could stab someone.

You can read some of our previous coverage on Nintendo’s worldwide crackdown on the R4DS carts here, here, here, and here. Including where they won (Britain) and lost (France).

Share this post: